Feeling vs. Feelings

Here's something to conjure with...

Making Distinctions

How many times on broadcast news programmes do you hear a journalist ask “What do you feel about…..? This has crept into common usage over the years, perhaps in an attempt to soften the more confronting phrase, “What do you think about..…?

Have you noticed this?

Some time ago I read a text by a professor of neuro-psychology with the heading Thinking and Feeling. “The distinction between thinking and feeling”, he wrote, “is absolutely fundamental to understanding the mind”. But, immediately in the next sentence he wrote, “I argue that feelings represent problems, needs, demands upon the mind to perform…”

Notice the switch from feeling to feelings. It is all too easy to slip into a switch without realising the significance of the difference:
‘feeling’, a gerund or verbal noun, (I am feeling such and such...)
to ‘feelings’, a noun, (My feelings are overwhelming me).

Feeling and feelings

To me the gerund feeling, represents a wholly different world of experience from the noun, ‘feelings’.

‘Feelings’ arise with emotional energy. Some bring strong signals: some weak. They come from a nearly unconscious reaction to something going on around you. They are quick as lightning. They are so basic that the first emotional response is a fast reaction habit.
- Positive or negative.
- For or against.
- Yes or No.

Sometimes people go from feelings to action impelled by the urgency of their emotional energy with very little consciousness in between.
Dangerous - sometimes.
Delightful - sometimes.

When thinking takes a look at feelings it is ‘feeling’ the feelings.

When you are in the mode of considering and identifying what your emotional or physical feelings are, you are then raising them to a consciousness of ‘feeling’. Feeling aims to name the feelings. You are questioning yourself about them, “What am I feeling?”.
This is thoughtful, and hopefully, penetrating thinking.

 

Here at the Centre for Effective Intelligence we have a vocabulary of thinking where ‘feeling’ (the verb) is named as the thinking operation of ‘interpreting’. When you are reflecting on your feelings and deciphering just what they might imply, you are trying to ‘interpret’ what guidance they can give you in understanding your own reactions to what is going on around you.

Sometimes it is wise to postpone reflection till later, in calmer waters, when you can think with less of the force of an immediate emotion. Sometimes it takes a bit of time to be able to put a finger on just what your feelings are telling you.

WIth your thinking you can look at feelings and give a name to them: “Ah!” you say to yourself, “I feel angry… surprised… upset… joyful… glad… puzzled… etc…” As soon as you say “I feel…” you have lifted some rather unconscious feelings out from the raw energy of their emotional power into the realm of conscious thinking where you can better handle them.

Pause for thought

That’s why it is so essential to be able to pause your reactions when you have ‘feelings’, so that you can switch on your thinking to penetrate (i.e. to ‘feel’) just what they mean to you. For instance, as soon as you say, “I’m furious with our government”, your anger is given the light of language and you can somewhat alleviate your emotions if you then add that magic connector... “because…”

Of course you can let your feelings push you around, which can be fun in the spirit of risky and spontaneous living. However, an extensive vocabulary for feelings is a valuable tool for thought. I have a friend who has a phrase he uses whenever he wants to raise something that could be contentious: “I am puzzled about…. because…” It’s a useful phrase and I recommend its judicious use.

How rich is your vocabulary of feeling? Marshall Rosenberg’s book on non-violent communication* provides a treasure-trove of descriptive words both positive and negative. Here’s just a few:

Positives: I feel -
adventurous – engaged – excited – fascinated – friendly – playful – confident – glad – relaxed – curious – thrilled – energetic
Negatives: I feel
irritated – embarrassed – anxious – alarmed – exasperated – ambivalent – annoyed – protective – confused - discouraged - impatient

 

*Non-Violent Communication by Marshall B Rosenberg

Photos on all blogs under licence from Canva unless supplied by the authors.